Back to Blog
Are DAOs Legal? Legal Status by Jurisdiction and the Risks for Members

Are DAOs Legal? Legal Status by Jurisdiction and the Risks for Members

Taking part in a DAO isn't illegal, but few laws give a DAO its own legal status. Where DAOs can register, and the risks for members until they do.

MIDAO
March 01, 2024
Updated November 03, 2026

The members of a DAO (a decentralized autonomous organization) vote to hire a developer, the treasury pays, and the work goes wrong. The developer, or a customer the work was for, wants to sue. Sue whom? If the DAO never registered as a legal entity, the answer depends on how a court classifies it, and one possible answer is the people who held the tokens and voted. That gap, more than legality itself, is what the question "are DAOs legal?" is usually about.

Key takeaways

  • Taking part in a DAO is not illegal in itself. What most legal systems lack is a legal form that gives a DAO its own status.
  • A DAO without an adopted legal form is assessed under applicable law in light of its actual arrangements, and that law decides whether it can act in its own name and whether its members face personal liability.
  • Operating without a registered entity leaves DAO participants exposed: courts have allowed general-partnership allegations against such groups to proceed, though none of those rulings decided that members are personally liable.
  • The Marshall Islands, Wyoming, Tennessee, Utah, Vermont and New Hampshire have laws that give a DAO or blockchain-governed organization a legal form, and Wyoming and Alabama also offer the DUNA (decentralized unincorporated nonprofit association), a nonprofit association form.
  • A Marshall Islands DAO LLC can designate a smart contract as its legal manager, so valid on-chain decisions can bind the company without separate human approval.

Are DAOs legal?

Yes. Several US states and the Marshall Islands have passed laws written for DAOs, and in England and Wales the Law Commission's 2024 review of DAOs found "no current need to develop a DAO-specific legal entity."

The harder question is what a DAO is in law. Being legal and being a legal entity are different things. Most jurisdictions have no form built for DAOs, so a DAO that hasn't registered as one is classified under whatever existing law fits. Its activities are also regulated like anyone else's: when the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) brought an enforcement action against Ooki DAO, it sued the DAO itself.

Is a DAO a legal entity?

Only if a law gives it that status. A DAO LLC exists once it is registered, and a Wyoming DUNA that meets that statute's conditions, including at least 100 members and a common nonprofit purpose, is treated as a legal entity separate from its members. A DAO with no such form is assessed under applicable law in light of its actual arrangements: its participants may form a partnership, an association, a network of contracts or another arrangement, and the rules that apply decide whether it can act in its own name and whether members face personal liability.

Courts and regulators reach for the categories they already have. The CFTC argued that Ooki DAO was an unincorporated association of the token holders who voted on its proposals. Plaintiffs in the bZx DAO and Lido DAO cases argued that token holders formed a general partnership. Under general partnership law in most US states, partners can be personally liable for the partnership's debts, which is why that theory matters to anyone who votes.

The form a DAO adopts decides what the law sees. DAO Science researcher Tara Merk puts the classification problem plainly: "If I incorporate as a Cayman trust, then it's a DAO but also really a Cayman trust." Her point is that the legal form comes first: a DAO set up as a Cayman trust is, in law, a trust, and a DAO registered as an LLC is an LLC.

Where do DAOs have their own legal status?

A small number of jurisdictions let a DAO register as a legal entity with the features DAOs need, such as membership defined by tokens, on-chain records and, in some cases, a smart contract as manager.

JurisdictionLawIn effectLegal form
Marshall IslandsDecentralized Autonomous Organization Act 2022, amended in 2023, and the DAO Regulations 20242022DAO LLC, for-profit or non-profit
WyomingDecentralized Autonomous Organization Supplement to the LLC ActJuly 1, 2021DAO LLC
WyomingDecentralized Unincorporated Nonprofit Association (DUNA) ActJuly 1, 2024DUNA, a nonprofit association
TennesseeDecentralized organization provisions of the LLC Act (Public Chapter 852 of 2022)April 20, 2022LLC organized as a decentralized organization
UtahDecentralized Autonomous Organization Act, enacted by H.B. 357 of 2023, now Utah Code Title 16, Chapter 22January 1, 2024Decentralized autonomous organization
VermontBlockchain-based LLC provisions (Act 205 of 2018)July 1, 2018Blockchain-based LLC
New HampshireRSA 301-B, Decentralized Autonomous Organizations (Laws of 2024, chapter 263)July 1, 2025Decentralized autonomous organization
AlabamaDecentralized Unincorporated Nonprofit Association Law (SB277 of 2026)October 1, 2026DUNA
Abu Dhabi Global Market (ADGM)Distributed Ledger Technology Foundations Regulations 20232023DLT foundation

Elsewhere, DAOs use general-purpose entities. In the Cayman Islands the usual choice is a foundation company under the Foundation Companies Act 2017; in Switzerland, an association or a foundation. In England and Wales, the Law Commission's July 2024 scoping paper suggested further work on a limited liability not-for-profit association rather than a DAO entity.

A statute on the books is not the same as a framework that works. Our look at what any DAO law has to get right holds these laws up to five design questions, and the comparisons with a Wyoming DUNA and a Cayman foundation go entity by entity.

What are the legal or financial risks of participating in a DAO?

For a member of an unregistered DAO, the main risks are personal liability for the DAO's debts and conduct, regulatory action over what the DAO does, and uncertainty over how its tokens are treated. Three US cases show how the liability risk has played out so far:

  • CFTC v. Ooki DAO (N.D. Cal.). The CFTC sued the DAO itself as an unincorporated association of its voting token holders and served it through the help-desk chat box on its website. No one appeared to defend it, and in June 2023 the court entered a default judgment against the DAO: a $643,542 penalty and a permanent injunction. The court did not decide whether individual voters are personally liable.
  • Sarcuni v. bZx DAO (S.D. Cal.). At the motion-to-dismiss stage in March 2023, the court found the plaintiffs had stated facts sufficient to allege a general partnership among the token holders, and let the negligence claims proceed. The parties later dismissed the case without a ruling on the merits.
  • Samuels v. Lido DAO (N.D. Cal.). At the motion-to-dismiss stage in November 2024, the court found the plaintiff had plausibly alleged that Lido DAO is a general partnership under California law, and let the claims proceed against the investors alleged to have taken part in its governance. Claims against an investor alleged only to have bought and held the token were dismissed, because holding alone did not plead participation in governance. The case is stayed pending an appeal.

None of these rulings held individual members personally liable. Ooki's judgment ran against the DAO; in bZx and Lido, the courts let claims against alleged partners go forward, so active participants can be drawn into litigation over decisions the DAO made. Our breakdown of what the courts decided in the Ooki DAO and Lido DAO cases goes through each ruling.

Two more risks apply whether or not the DAO registers, and a third comes from not registering:

  • Regulation of what the DAO does. Securities, commodities, sanctions, tax and data-protection rules apply to a DAO's activities in each country where it operates, the way they apply to a company's. Registering an entity does not remove them. Ooki DAO's penalty came from a regulator, not a private plaintiff.
  • Token classification. Whether a governance token is a security depends on the law of each market it reaches. The Marshall Islands' 2023 amendment added a securities carve-out for the governance tokens of non-profit DAO LLCs, but no single statute settles how US securities law treats a token. Our guide to token issuance and securities law covers that question.
  • Operations. Banks and counterparties generally want a registered entity to deal with, so without one a member often opens the account, signs the contract or hires people in a personal capacity, and carries the risk that comes with it.

How do DAOs reduce their legal risk?

The main step is to register the DAO as a legal entity, often called a legal wrapper. The entity can sign contracts and hold assets in its own name. How far it protects members, and how it is taxed, depend on its form, the law that governs it and the participants' own conduct. How far an LLC's protection reaches is covered in our guide to the corporate veil and liability protection for DAO members.

Not every entity fits a DAO equally well. The questions to ask of any jurisdiction are whether membership can follow token holdings instead of a name-and-address register, whether on-chain records count as official, whether a smart contract can act as the manager, and how governance tokens are classified. The Marshall Islands framework supports all four: membership based on governance tokens, on-chain records and a smart contract as manager, as set out in the organization's governing documents, plus a securities carve-out under Marshall Islands law for the governance tokens of non-profit DAO LLCs. Registration requires verification of the organization's beneficial owners or, where there are none, an authorized representative member, rather than every token holder, and the law provides for approval and registration within 30 days of a compliant application.

Where should you start?

Merk also points to a longer-term question she calls "exit to community": "Why big internet platforms and sharing economy platforms like Twitter, Airbnb, and Uber aren't run by the people who use them and contribute to them… Why don't we have a say in those platforms, and maybe a revenue share, including employees?"

Whatever the purpose, start with what the organization does and who governs it. A DAO LLC is a legal designation, not an identity requirement: protocol teams, NFT projects, investment DAOs and AI agent builders use the same structure, because the question it answers is the same for all of them: who the law sees when the organization acts.

MIDAO is the registered agent for DAO LLCs formed under the Marshall Islands framework. Talk to the MIDAO team about the structure your organization needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which Marshall Islands laws govern DAO LLCs?

The Decentralized Autonomous Organization Act 2022, amended in 2023, and the DAO Regulations 2024. Both for-profit and non-profit DAO LLCs are available under the framework, and the 2023 amendment added a securities carve-out for the governance tokens of non-profit DAO LLCs.

What was missing from existing legal structures that DAO-specific legislation was written to address?

Conventional entities were built for members with known names and human decision-makers. Depending on the form and the jurisdiction, that can mean a board or named managers, a register of members' names and addresses, and paper records of decisions, which fit token-based membership and on-chain governance poorly. The Marshall Islands framework supports token-based membership, on-chain records and smart-contract management within a registered DAO LLC; other jurisdictions offer different forms and features.

Does a DAO LLC give token holders binding legal control, or just an advisory vote?

It can give token holders real legal control. A Marshall Islands DAO LLC can designate a smart contract as the entity's legal manager, so with governing documents that provide for it, a valid on-chain decision binds the company without a human approving it afterward. Not every DAO legal structure works this way.

Is a DAO a general partnership?

It can be treated as one if it has no registered entity. In the bZx DAO and Lido DAO cases, courts found that the plaintiffs had plausibly alleged a general partnership among token holders and let the claims proceed. Those rulings did not decide that individual members are personally liable.

Are DAOs legal in the UK?

England and Wales have no DAO-specific legal entity. The Law Commission's July 2024 scoping paper found "no current need to develop a DAO-specific legal entity for England and Wales" and suggested further work on a limited liability not-for-profit association instead.